Rev up the bureaucratic turbines, because a judge in Texas has determined that
warrantless cellphone tracking
is indeed unconstitutional. In a brief decision issued earlier this
month, US District Judge Lynn N. Hughes of the Southern District of
Texas argued that seizing cellphone records without a search warrant
constitutes a violation of the Fourth Amendment. "The records would show
the date, time, called number, and location of the telephone when the
call was made," Judge Hughes wrote in the ruling, linked below. "These
data are constitutionally protected from this intrusion." The decision
comes in response to an earlier ruling issued last year by Magistrate
Judge Stephen Smith, also of the Southern District of Texas. In that
case, Judge Smith argued against unwarranted wiretapping on similarly
constitutional grounds, pointing out that with today's tracking
technology, every aspect of a suspect's life could be "imperceptibly
captured, compiled, and retrieved from a digital dossier somewhere in a
computer cloud."
The federal government appealed Judge Smith's ruling on the grounds
that the Fourth Amendment would not apply to cellphone tracking, because
"a customer has no privacy interest in business records held by a cell
phone provider, as they are not the customer's private papers." Judge
Hughes' decision, however, effectively overrules this appeal. "When the
government requests records from cellular services, data disclosing the
location of the telephone at the time of particular calls may be
acquired only by a warrant issued on probable cause," Judge Hughes
wrote. "The standard under [today's law] is below that required by the
Constitution." The law in question, of course, is the Stored
Communications Act -- a law bundled under the Electronic Communications
Privacy Act of 1986, which allows investigators to obtain electronic
records without a warrant. This month's decision implicitly calls for
this law to be reconsidered or revised, though it's certainly
not the only ruling to challenge it, and it likely
won't be the last, either.